Pomeroy's Garage - (973) 992-5669 CALLPomeroy's Garage - (973) 992-5669 HOURSPomeroy's Garage - (973) 992-5669 MAP

Customer Reviews for Pomeroy's Garage

We love hearing what our customers have to say!

We want you to be completely satisfied with our service, so please let us know how we’re doing.

If you have a review you’d like to share, click the button below and fill out the form below.


Here’s what some of our Livingston, NJ customers are saying about us:

Finding a god mechanic is not easy. So, I feel really lucky to have found Pomeroy's Garage. They are clearly very experienced and great at diagnosing problems. And they don't pile on lot's of unnecessary work. Highly recommended!

Tim StrassmaierGoogle Review

Great local garage with friendly service. They fixed an air conditioning issue for a fraction of the price quoted by the dealer who wanted to replace most of the system. An honest local garage. They have been very accommodating to my family and I. Going here is like stepping back in time to a garage in a friendly small town. Highly recommend them!

Don BenderPomeroy's Garage Customer Review

Great service and honest. I visited from another state and I'm going back to this garage.

Christian LeeGoogle Review

I have taken my cars over the years to them for various repairs and service - some of the repairs one would have thought only a dealer would do. They have handled everything flawlessly and quickly. Their prices are fair and they have tried to save me money by taking advantage of "specials" when available by manufacturers. I have and will continue to recommend them to my friends.

Tom WaldronPomeroy's Garage Customer Review

My 2001 Toyota Camry has 153,000+ miles on it, and if I really, really wanted to keep it for another ten years, I have every confidence that with Rick's help, it would not be a problem. But, maybe I'm ready for something new. Still, I have to thank Rick and Gary for keeping my wife (with her own Camry) and I on the road for almost as long as we've lived in town, about 40 years. I hope they stay in business for at least 40 more years, at which time, I will be around 109 years old. With all the electric cars coming out now, I bet gas will be way less expensive by then. Can't wait to save.

Mike KorsonskyPomeroy's Garage Customer Review

My family and I have been going here for over 30 years. Rick is the most honest mechanic I have ever met.

Mark CarlsonGoogle Review

Our family has been going to Pomeroy's Garage for three generations. Would not dream of going anywhere else.

Mrs. Maureen WehrfritzGoogle Review

What a great experience. I went into to check out a rattle on my Subaru. We live in town and my husband always takes his car to Rick. Rick quickly figured out the problem and was able to get the car back to me that day. He was honest and capable, the price was fair. Who knew it, my husband was right. Definitely a good experience.

5 FlavorsGoogle Review

Rick is really kind and patient, he always provides all feasible options / solutions before making any decision and explains pros and cons to let you make best choice. Highly recommend!

Thales ZengGoogle Review

My wife and I moved to Livingston in 1993 and since then Rick and Gary have been taking care of all of our cars. Some of our kids now have their own cars and they also take them to Pomeroy's. Overall they do great honest work with fair prices.

Oren DavidGoogle Review

My family has been doing business for almost 60 years with this exceptional family-run business. Gary and Rick provide outstanding service, with respect and integrity.

Hilde LevineGoogle Review

I always prefer to use the services of local, family owned enterprises, when such are available, rather than using 'big box' stores that may be able to do the work, but don't have the same vested interest to do great work to ensure repeat business. When I came to Pomeroy's Garage with internal water leakage an exhaust issue, my expectations for quality work were high, but the end result exceeded my anticipations. Rick Pomeroy knew that the work that would have been done by a competitor was only half of the job and would have meant a repeat visit, he recommended a full exhaust system replacement. The price was more than fair, the work was expertly done, and he even had the old-fashioned respect for his work and his clients to top off the work by adding the cosmetic but attractive tail spout to the muffler, a feature that made my old car look like new, not to mention, putting a smile on my face. Pomeroy's Garage, please accept my business for many years to come!

Andrew ClarkeGoogle Review

I have been using Pomeroy's for over 10 years at the suggestion of my neighbor who used them for decades. They have always serviced my 3 vehicles with honesty and integrity. They always explain the work done and inform me of any potential problem or future maintenance . Years ago, I had a starter installed and after about 1 year later, it failed and they informed me it was still under warranty. I was not expecting that. They are not out to make a quick buck. They treat you as the neighbor you are and have provided me with great service always.

hhueydoGoogle Review

I've been doing business with Pomeroy's for 30 years. The very first time I went to them they I had a broken head gasket. Tony came in on a Saturday and did the job. When I went to pick it up Tony said you only needed half the head done. The price was half of what I expected. That was the first time 30 years ago. First place I go for any problem is Pomeroy's. Anthony DiTringo

Anthony DiTringoGoogle Review

Pomeroy's Garage is excellent. Brothers Rick & Gary service our vehicles & are always honest and highly competent. Believe it or not, their father serviced my parent's cars going back many decades.

Daniel RudyGoogle Review

Since 1947, Pomeroy's Garage has been an icon in the community known for expert car repair and towing. Pomeroy's technicians are fully-certified and offer the highest standard in automotive care, customer service and reasonable prices. My family has been a loyal customer for over 35 years. Next time your car needs any servicing, forgoe pricey dealerships, and stick with the masters--Pomeroy's Garage.

Kelley W.Yelp Review

I went into to check out a rattle on my Subaru. We live in town and my husband always goes to Rick with his car. I went along with his suggestion and brought the car in. What a great experience. Rick took the time to figure out the problem and was able to get the car back to me that day. He was honest and capable. Who knew it, my husband was right. Definitely a good experience.

Pam S.Yelp Review

My whole family has been coming to Pomeroy's for as long as I can remember, probably like 15+ years. Rick and Gary are great! Honest, reliable, and reasonably priced. Never had a bad experience with them. They are always pleasant to deal with. All around great customer service and repairs.

Deb F.Yelp Review

Absolutely amazing!!! Fair and honest are the first two words to describe Pomeroys!!! These guys are so helpful and wound up saving me money too!!! This is the place to go!!!

Shari S.Yelp Review

Outstanding! Reliable, trustworthy, and skilled. I have trusted Rick and Gary with my cars for the past 30 years. They do everything from standard maintenance to hard core car repairs. They take perfect care of my classic car too (66 mustang). I would highly recommend them!

Jeff K.Yelp Review

Recommended with the highest accolades.

Quality work at a fair price, done in a timely manner, and politely so. What more can you ask and where else can you get this level of service?

I have now used them for several repairs and I could not be happier.

Larry F.Yelp Review

I recommend this garage without a moment's hesitation. I started using them after getting enthusiastic recommendations from three of my friends when I was looking for a garage when I moved to Livingston in 1998. Rick and Gary and their staff have been servicing our cars for over sixteen years. I completely trust them to do a good job and not over-bill me. They recently serviced our Lexus for 1/3 of what the dealership wanted to charge me for the same service.

M G.Yelp Review

I have been using Pomoroy's for more than 20 years - from the time a local service station recommended them to fix a difficult problem.Their service level and their courteousness are excellent - and their prices are reasonable. They take appointments (and they will drive local customers back home and drop the car off after completion). Rick and Gary (the owners) are very easy to deal with and they explain all issues at an understandable level to those of us who are not mechanics. I unequivocally recommend Pomoroy's to all my friends!

Alan S.Yelp Review

This is the best auto shop in Essex County. These are the most trustworthy, knowledgable mechanics in the area and I trust them without reservation. I offer them my highest recommendation to anyone looking for a great auto shop for any car issues that you have.

Matt C.Yelp Review

Excellent professional service you can trust, very skillful.

Leo L.YellowPages Review

Professional, honest and pragmatic car repair. I have been taking my cars to Rick and Gary for many years. Their trust, helpfulness, and friendliness is outstanding.

Kenneth B.YellowPages Review

Pomeroy Repair serves the public in a professional and caring manner.I commend the Pomeroy Brothers for their service to the community.


Hy K.YellowPages Review

these guys are as honest as the day is long and have many years of experiance

Patricia P.YellowPages Review

Add Your Own Review!